Did you change how you wrote the emails after you saw that? For me the game changer was treating the list like a group chat instead of a bulletin board. I stopped writing polished updates and just sent short, plain notes about one thing, like a heads up about a restock or a quick story about a mess up. The open rate jumped and people actually hit reply, which never happened before. Once folks started replying, those same people began sharing the links on their own, and that drove way more traffic than any paid post ever did for us. Small list, real voices, way better payoff than chasing likes.