Butter vs shortening in my pie crust, and I picked the wrong one
I had to pick between butter and shortening for a apple pie I brought to my sister's place in Fresno last Saturday. I went with shortening because my mom always swore it made the crust flakier, and I wanted that flaky look for the family. Big mistake, the crust came out pale and kind of bland, and my brother in law said it tasted like a cracker. The filling was fine but the crust just had no flavor at all and I could tell people were being polite. Now I'm wondering if I should do half butter half shortening next time or just go all butter and chill it longer. What do you all use and does the butter version really hold its shape or does it slump?