Rant: my butter was too soft and 24 chocolate chip cookies turned into one giant sheet
I was making cookies for my niece's birthday party in Naperville last Saturday and got distracted by a phone call while the butter sat out on the counter. By the time I creamed it into the sugar it was basically melted, and the dough spread into one sad sheet cookie about 14 inches wide in the oven. I let it cool, broke it into shards, and served them in a bowl like cookie brittle, which honestly got more compliments than the normal batch ever does. Now I'm scared to try chilling the dough because I don't want to wait an extra hour. Has anyone else just leaned into the fail and called it a new recipe?
The "cookie brittle" thing is real, I read a baking blog last year that said over-melted butter just means you get a thinner, crispier cookie and people shouldn't panic about it. The trick they mentioned was lining the pan and scoring the slab while it's still warm so it breaks into neat pieces instead of random shards. Scoring it warm is the part I would have never thought of on my own. And honestly the chilling thing is overblown if you ask me, a half hour in the fridge is usually enough and you can do the dishes while you wait.