Warning: the library in my town has a first drafts shelf and I can't tell if it helps or hurts
I was at the public library in Boise last Saturday and saw a whole shelf labeled "Rough Drafts" with early versions of published novels, and it got me thinking. One side says it helps new writers see that even famous books started messy, so people stop being scared to share their own bad first tries. The other side says it just makes people compare their unfinished work to someone else's finished product, and that's not fair. I counted 14 books on that shelf and every single one had a note saying the final version was rewritten at least twice, which honestly made me feel better about my own pile of junk. But a guy next to me said he felt worse after seeing it, like his drafts would never get that good. Do you think showing early drafts in public helps or hurts people who are just starting out?