The difference between a cheap graphite paddle and a good one is a ruined piece
I bought a basic graphite paddle from a general craft store for about twelve dollars, thinking it would be fine for simple shaping. It worked okay for a week, but then it started to shed these tiny black graphite flecks onto the hot glass. I didn't notice at first, but it left these permanent, gritty marks in a clear paperweight I was making. I switched to a more expensive paddle from a proper glass supplier, which cost me forty five bucks. The surface is way smoother and it's been heat-treated better, so it doesn't flake at all. The glass just glides over it now, and I don't get those annoying inclusions. It seems like a small thing, but it makes shaping so much cleaner and less stressful. Has anyone else had a tool that seemed fine until it ruined a good piece?